Insurance Archaeology

Environmental Proof of Claims Services

After an insurer becomes insolvent, policyholders may face a limited window to submit claims. Restorical Research helps property owners identify historical insurance coverage, research environmental liabilities, and gather information to support proof-of-claim submissions — even when original policy documents are missing. 

Find Your Policy
Our Service

What is a Proof of Claims?

When an insurance company becomes insolvent and enters receivership or liquidation, a receiver or other appointed administrator oversees the process of addressing its outstanding obligations. Policyholders who believe they have a claim may need to submit a formal document called a proof of claim to establish that claim against the insurer’s estate.

The process can be challenging when a claim involves environmental contamination or other liabilities connected to events that occurred decades earlier. Property owners may need to identify the insurance policies that were in place at that time and gather supporting documentation, all while working within the applicable claims deadline.

Historical insurance records can be difficult to find, especially when a property has changed hands, a business has closed, or an insurer has merged with another company or ceased operating. Without those records, property owners may have trouble identifying coverage that could be relevant to their claim.

Restorical Research specializes in insurance archaeology and claims management: We investigate historical insurance coverage and the records surrounding past liabilities. Our team helps clients identify potential coverage, research the underlying circumstances, and organize information that can support the proof-of-claim process.
 

View Case studies
The Process

How We Help With Proof of Claims

Our team combines insurance archaeology with historical research and claims support to help clients build a stronger record for the proof-of-claim process. Our experience with historical insurance records allows us to investigate coverage even when a client’s own records leave gaps.
View All Clients
01

Research Historical Insurance

We search for historical insurance policies, even lost insurance policies, and other records that can help establish what coverage was in place during the relevant period.

This can include identifying insurers, policy periods, policy numbers, coverage types, and other details that may no longer be readily available in a company’s current records.

02

Reconstruct Missing Policies

Sometimes a client knows an insurer provided coverage but doesn’t have the original policy documents. Our research can help reconstruct missing insurance information using historical records, carrier-specific information, archival sources, and our proprietary database of historical policies.

03

Research the Underlying Liability

Historical insurance is only one part of an environmental claim. We may also investigate the history of the property, business operations, contamination, environmental investigations, regulatory activity, and other records relevant to the liability. Understanding the site history can help establish how the insurance coverage relates to the claim.

04

Organize Claim Documentation

Proof-of-claim submissions require supporting information. Depending on the circumstances, that may include historical policies, environmental records, financial documentation, property records, and other evidence. We continue to support clients through the claims process by researching and organizing additional information as needed.

05

Oversee and Support the Claims Process

Once the claim has been prepared and submitted, property owners may need to respond to additional questions or requests for documentation from the receiver or other parties involved in the claims process. They don’t have to go it alone. We continue to support clients by researching and organizing additional information as needed. We’ll work alongside their legal and other professional advisors to help support the claims process.

Situations Where Proof of Claims Research May Be Necessary

When a property owner is dealing with an insurer that is in receivership, they may feel a great sense of urgency to resolve their claim before the deadline expires. They may be dealing with a claims bar date, or legal deadline by which policyholders, injured third parties, and other creditors must submit their formal “proof of claim” forms to the appointed receiver.

A claims bar date may give a policyholder or property owner a limited amount of time to identify potential claims, research historical coverage, gather supporting documentation, and submit the required materials. This can create a particular challenge for environmental claims. Researching decades-old insurance coverage and property history takes time, particularly when records are incomplete or multiple insurers are involved.

Beginning the process as early as possible can give clients more time to identify potential coverage and prepare the documentation required by the claims process. There are certain scenarios where historical insurance research can be especially important.

Environmental Contamination

Contamination discovered today may be connected to operations or releases that occurred decades earlier. Historical policies may provide an avenue for addressing some of the resulting costs, depending on the specific circumstances and applicable coverage.

Historical Property Liabilities

Properties can change ownership multiple times, making it difficult to determine which historical insurance policies may be relevant to an environmental issue. Researching the property’s ownership, use, and insurance history can help fill gaps in the record.

Multiple Insurance Policies or Carriers

Long-running environmental liabilities may span multiple policy periods and insurers. Identifying the applicable policies and organizing the coverage history can be an important part of preparing a claim.

Missing Insurance Records

A company may know that it carried insurance during a particular period without having the original policies available. Historical research may uncover information that helps identify or reconstruct that coverage.

What Goes Into Proof-of-Claim Research

Proof-of-claim research often involves several connected areas of investigation. Historical insurance records may be incomplete, multiple policies may need to be evaluated, and the underlying liability may require additional research. Restorical Research treats these avenues of exploration as part of our process. By integrating these elements, we help clients develop a clearer picture of the historical coverage and circumstances relevant to their claims.

This work may involve locating missing insurance policies, reconstructing policy information, researching a property’s history, and organizing documentation to support the claims process. Our goal is to establish the connection between historical insurance coverage and the underlying liability.

Finding Lost Insurance Policies

Finding historical policies is often the first step in determining whether a potential claim exists. Restorical Research searches for lost or overlooked insurance policies using historical records, carrier information, and other sources to identify coverage that may no longer appear in a client’s current files.

Insurance Policy Reconstruction

When a property owner can’t locate an original insurance policy, Restorical Research can use secondary evidence to reconstruct historical coverage. This may include carrier records, premium information, archival sources, and other documentation that can help establish the terms of a missing policy.

Site History

Understanding the history of a property or business can help establish how an environmental liability developed and which insurance policies may be relevant. Restorical Research reconstructs ownership, operations, and other aspects of a property’s history to help connect historical coverage with the underlying claim.

Insurance Allocation Analysis

Environmental claims can involve multiple policy years and insurance carriers. Insurance allocation analysis helps determine how a loss or liability may be distributed across applicable policies, giving clients and their advisors a clearer picture of the coverage available to support a claim.

Claims Management

The work doesn’t necessarily end when a proof of claim is submitted. Restorical Research can continue to support clients throughout the claims process, helping research additional information, organize documentation, and respond to questions or requests that arise as a claim is evaluated.

PFAS Cleanup

Case Studies

Case Study

Public Works

Read More
Case Study

Residential Heating Oil Tank

Read More
Case Study

Farming And Agricultural

Read More
Proof of Claims

FAQs – Environmental Proof of Claims

A proof of claim is a formal submission made during an insurer’s receivership or liquidation process to establish a policyholder’s claim against the insurance estate. The specific information and documentation required depend on the applicable claims process.

A claims bar date is the deadline established for submitting a proof of claim. Missing the deadline can affect a claimant’s ability to participate in the claims process, so it is important to understand the applicable requirements as soon as possible.

In many cases, we can research historical insurance coverage even when the original policy is unavailable. Restorical Research uses historical records, carrier-specific information, archival sources, and its proprietary policy database to identify and reconstruct historical coverage.

Potentially. The answer depends on the circumstances of the contamination, the applicable insurance policies, and the terms of those policies. Historical insurance research can help identify the policies and coverage information that may be relevant to the liability.

Not necessarily. An insurer’s insolvency or entry into receivership can create a separate claims process for policyholders. Historical policies may still be relevant to a claim, although the applicable procedures and potential recovery depend on the specific receivership.

To begin the proof of claims process, you’ll need any available insurance policies, correspondence with the insurer, and records of the environmental issue in question. Our team can help you identify and gather the necessary information if you’re missing some of these documents.

In cases where the insurance company no longer maintains records, we utilize alternative sources, such as our proprietary insurance archives, state records, industry archives, and other historical data repositories, to reconstruct the details of your policy and support your claim.

20+

Years in Business

Allows us to be the leading insurance archaeology and claims management firm in the country

$200M+

Million Recovered

We uncover hidden assets for our clients, and we excel at obtaining coverage for their environmental liabilities

100%

Policyholder Clients Served

We only work for policyholders and property owners and do not offer our services to insurance companies

21,000+

Historical Policy Database

Restorical has been collecting, analyzing, and cataloging historical insurance policies spanning the 1950s-1990s.

Our proprietary database with carrier-specific detail is leveraged for our clients on a daily basis