Insurance Archaeology

Environmental Responsibility in Business and Real Estate

Ben Pariser

TABLE OF CONTENTS

On This Page

Corporate environmental responsibility is a necessary part of doing business. This applies to small businesses, commercial property owners, and the private sector, facing increased scrutiny from regulators, lenders, investors, and the communities they serve. Whether you’re operating an auto shop, managing farmland, leasing out space to industrial tenants, or operating in other business markets, your environmental impact can have legal, financial, and operational consequences. Taking responsibility means actively managing your risks, protecting the long-term value of your assets, and preparing for unexpected issues that may arise from current operations or past site use.

This article explains environmental management and responsibility in a business and property context, the most common risks you may face, and practical steps to reduce liability and protect your investment.

What Is Environmental Responsibility in a Business or Property Context?

Environmental responsibility means actively identifying, managing, and minimizing the environmental risks associated with your operations or land. It includes managing waste, preventing pollution, and minimizing energy consumption to reduce environmental impact. For small business owners, that involves handling materials safely, following disposal regulations, and preventing spills or emissions. For property owners, it means understanding the environmental history of a site and addressing contamination as soon as it’s discovered. 

Many business and property owners mistakenly believe they have nothing to worry about if they’re not actively polluting, but environmental responsibility includes legacy risks —  problems that may be buried underground, hidden in site records, or left behind by someone else.

In short, environmental responsibility is about recognizing how your business or property’s past, present, and future interact with environmental regulations, health, and liability.

Types of Environmental Problems Found in Businesses and Properties

Environmental risks often go unnoticed until a loan, inspection, redevelopment plan, or legal notice brings them to light. At that point, the consequences can escalate quickly. Small business owners and property owners face different types of exposure, but both are vulnerable to site-specific and legacy issues that can threaten the future of their investment.

For small business owners

Routine operations can create environmental problems, especially in the fuel, solvents, pesticides, or hazardous materials industries. Common risks include:

  • Leaking underground or aboveground storage tanks (e.g., fuel, oil, waste tanks)
  • Chemical spills or overflows from drums, sinks, or work areas
  • Improper disposal of hazardous waste or contaminated materials
  • Runoff or overspray from outdoor vehicle washing, pesticide use, or cleaning processes
  • Poorly maintained shop floors or drains that allow contaminants to enter the soil or groundwater
  • Failure to train staff on proper storage, handling, or emergency response procedures
  • Unpermitted air emissions, such as greenhouse gas emissions from fumes or particulates from industrial processes
  • Improper labeling or storage of hazardous materials can lead to regulatory violations or fire hazards
  • Lack of secondary containment around tanks or drums to prevent leaks or overflows
  • Unmaintained emergency response equipment, like spill kits, eye wash stations, or fire controls

For commercial property owners

Many environmental risks come from a property’s history. If prior occupants caused contamination, the current owner could be liable. Common risks include:

  • Unregistered or forgotten underground storage tanks
  • Contaminated soil or groundwater from past commercial or agricultural activity
  • Vapor intrusion from volatile organic compounds (VOCs) migrating into occupied buildings, which can pose risks to indoor air quality and human health
  • Illegal dumping or burial of waste by former tenants or contractors
  • Abandoned drums, tanks, or chemical containers left behind in crawlspaces, yards, or basements
  • Lack of documentation about historical site use or tenant activity, complicating due diligence
  • Asbestos-containing materials in older buildings (e.g., insulation, tile, siding)
  • Lead-based paint or plumbing systems, especially in pre-1978 structures
  • Stormwater management failures, including missing or ineffective retention systems
  • Residual pesticide or herbicide contamination from agricultural or landscaping use

Legal and Financial Risks of Poor Environmental Management

Environmental responsibility has direct financial and legal implications for business and property owners. Regulators like the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) don’t always distinguish between owners and operators when enforcing environmental legislation. Both can be held accountable for pollution. Understanding why it matters helps you make better decisions, avoid costly mistakes, and protect the long-term value of your business or investment.

For small business owners

Small businesses often operate with limited resources, making them especially vulnerable to environmental risks. A single mistake or undiscovered issue can jeopardize their entire operation, leading to various consequences, including

  • Regulatory penalties for noncompliance with waste storage, emissions, or disposal laws
  • Lawsuits or claims from neighboring properties, municipalities, or regulators
  • Disruption of operations due to inspections, remediation, or forced shutdowns
  • Loss of permits or licenses following an environmental violation
  • Reputational damage that impacts customer trust or community standing
  • Ineligibility for public contracts or sustainability programs requiring compliance documentation
  • Higher insurance premiums or denied coverage after a reported environmental issue
  • Loss of access to parts of the site if regulators restrict use or require containment
  • Inherited risk from occupying or purchasing a site with historic contamination
  • Evolving climate change legislation that may impose stricter limits on emissions, energy use, or reporting requirements, especially for high-impact industries

For commercial property owners

Even without daily operations, owning land includes significant environmental responsibilities, especially if the site has an industrial or commercial past. Owners can be held liable for pollution, whether they caused it or not. Risks include:

  • Legal liability for contamination from past tenants or prior owners
  • Transaction delays or failed deals due to findings during environmental due diligence
  • Decreased property value because of pollution stigma or remediation costs
  • Lender requirements for environmental assessments, disclosures, or cleanup prior to financing
  • Unexpected cleanup costs triggered by inspections, redevelopment, or tenant activity
  • Tenant turnover or lease refusals driven by environmental safety concerns
  • Restrictive covenants are placed on a site after remediation, limiting future land use
  • Superfund site listing or equivalent state-level environmental designation
  • Difficulty obtaining property insurance or insurability gaps due to unresolved issues

What Small Businesses and Property Owners Can Do to Practice Environmental Responsibility

Taking proactive steps to manage environmental risks can help you avoid costly surprises, improve compliance, and preserve the value of your business or property. Whether you’re operating an active site or managing a portfolio of properties, these actions can reduce exposure and demonstrate socially responsible ownership.

  • Order a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA). This is the industry-standard first step for evaluating a property’s historical use. It’s especially important before buying, refinancing, or redeveloping land.
  • Inspect and maintain equipment and storage areas. Regularly check tanks, pipes, shop floors, loading zones, and drainage areas. Look for signs of wear, corrosion, or potential leaks.
  • Conduct a hazardous materials inventory. Keep a current list of all chemicals and fuels stored or used on-site. This helps you comply with reporting thresholds and identify storage risks.
  • Improve clean energy efficiency in operations and buildings. Upgrading lighting, HVAC systems, insulation, or equipment can lower energy use, reduce operating costs, and support broader environmental goals.
  • Implement environmental responsibility with secondary containment and spill control measures. Use spill pallets, berms, and other controls around hazardous material storage areas to prevent leaks from spreading.
  • Develop or update a spill prevention and emergency response plan. Create a written plan, such as a Spill Prevention, Control, and Countermeasure (SPCC) Plan or Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP), to meet legal requirements and guide staff during emergencies.
  • Monitor discharges from air emissions, wastewater, or stormwater systems. If your site releases fumes, rinsewater, or runoff, ensure the appropriate permits and monitoring systems are in place.
  • Review chemical handling and disposal protocols. Make sure all materials are stored, labeled, and disposed of according to local, state, and federal regulations.
  • Keep accurate records. Document waste disposal, equipment maintenance, inspections, environmental assessments, and organizational practices. Good recordkeeping can reduce liability and support regulatory compliance.
  • Train employees and contractors to increase environmental awareness. Ensure everyone working on-site understands environmental risks, safe sustainability practices, and emergency procedures. Many violations happen because of simple human error.
  • Perform routine environmental self-audits. Schedule periodic reviews of environmental behavior and compliance. Identifying issues early reduces enforcement risk and helps you correct problems before they escalate.
  • Audit past site use and tenant activity. If you own or manage property, create a timeline of former tenants and site uses. This can help identify potential contamination sources and prepare you for future due diligence questions.
  • Identify or review land use restrictions or institutional controls. If the site has undergone past remediation, make sure any activity or land-use limitations are known and followed to avoid re-triggering liability.
  • Stay informed about local regulations. Environmental rules vary by city and state. Be aware of reporting requirements, permitting obligations, and any industry-specific compliance standards.
  • Consider transitioning to renewable energy sources and sustainable materials. Where feasible, investing in solar, wind, or other sustainable resources can reduce carbon emissions and your carbon footprint, support climate change mitigation, and demonstrate a long-term commitment to promoting sustainability.

What You Can Do if Contamination Is Discovered

Discovering environmental contamination on your property or within your operations is serious, but manageable if you act quickly and follow the proper steps. Whether the issue is tied to your activity or left behind by someone else, this process will help you limit damage, meet your obligations, and begin a path toward improved environmental performance. Here are the steps to take immediately if you discover contamination:

  1. Stop the source of contamination if it’s ongoing. Shut off leaking equipment, isolate the area, and prevent further spread. Early containment reduces cleanup costs and helps demonstrate good faith.
  2. Hire a qualified environmental consultant. Bring in a licensed expert to conduct site testing, identify pollutants, and assess the extent of soil, water, or air contamination.
  3. Document the situation. Take photos, gather inspection reports, tenant history, maintenance records, and any environmental site assessments. This documentation will support your legal and financial response.
  4. Secure the site. If necessary, limit access to affected areas to protect employees, contractors, and nearby human beings from exposure by using fencing, signage, or physical barriers.
  5. Report the issue to the appropriate agency (if required). Depending on the type of contamination, you may need to notify your state environmental agency or the EPA. Your consultant can guide this process.
  6. Develop a remediation plan. Work with your consultant to outline a cleanup approach that meets regulatory standards. This may include excavation, chemical treatment, vapor mitigation, or long-term monitoring.
  7. Review your legal obligations and defenses. Speak with an environmental attorney to understand your liability and whether you qualify for legal protections such as the innocent landowner defense.

Funding Environmental Cleanup With Historical Insurance

If contamination traces back to past activity, whether by you, a prior owner or a prior tenant, you may be able to access funding through historical general liability insurance. Many older policies, especially those written before the mid-1980s, contain coverage for environmental damage. These policies may still apply even if:

  • The contamination occurred decades ago.
  • The policyholder is no longer in business.
  • The coverage belonged to a former owner or tenant.
  • The pollution was only recently discovered.

Recovering this coverage typically involves locating the original policies, linking them to the site and issue, and engaging with insurers. While the process can be complex, it may offer significant financial relief for investigation, cleanup, and legal defense costs.

Practicing Environmental Responsibility Protects Your Business and Property

Environmental stewardship and corporate responsibility don’t just reduce liability. It contributes to healthier communities, protects natural resources for future generations, and preserves the long-term value of what you own and operate. It also supports compliance, helps conserve natural resources, and contributes to a more sustainable future. Whether you’re a small business managing daily business operations or a property owner overseeing multiple sites, the risks tied to environmental degradation are real, and so are the consequences of inaction.

Taking proactive steps, like conducting site assessments, improving material handling, maintaining proper records, and investigating historical site use, can help you avoid costly surprises and strengthen your position in more sustainable future transactions or inspections. Knowing how to respond quickly and efficiently if contamination is discovered is key. In many cases, historical insurance policies may offer a path to funding that doesn’t drain your operating budget. If you believe past insurance policies may help offset the cost of cleanup or legal defense, working with a firm that specializes in historical insurance recovery can help you unlock coverage you didn’t know you had.

We are not attorneys, this is not legal advice. 
Author

Ben Pariser

One of Ben’s favorite parts of insurance archeology is knowing Restorical is making a difference, helping to clean up the environment one polluted property at a time while also changing people’s lives.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

On This Page