Insurance Archaeology

What to Know About Environmental Enforcement Actions

Ben Pariser

TABLE OF CONTENTS

On This Page

When someone acquires a new property, they have high hopes for it. Dealing with an environmental violation probably isn’t among those hopes. But if a government agency finds that the property violates environmental laws or regulations, or fails to meet environmental requirements, property owners can face significant issues.

Depending on the circumstances, they may need to correct a smaller regulatory violation. Or they could be compelled to conduct a larger investigation and cleanup of environmental contamination. This work can come with potentially substantial costs. As property owners plan to address the environmental issue, they might also wonder how to pay for the clean up.

Since many environmental problems  have long histories, it’s not unreasonable to believe that there might have been relevant insurance coverage attached to the property that could cover the current environmental liability. 

Learning more about what past policies might have covered can help property owners avoid shouldering the heavy financial burden of paying to address an environmental enforcement action. Sleuthing for these old policies can be quite complex, but property owners don’t need to play detective alone: Insurance archeologists can be crucial allies in identifying relevant coverage that can make the costs easier to bear.

What Is an Environmental Enforcement Action?

An environmental enforcement action is a formal action taken by a government agency to address a suspected or confirmed violation of an environmental law, regulation, permit, or other requirement.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and state environmental agencies are tasked with investigating potential environmental violations. These violations could involve improper handling or disposal of hazardous waste, releases of hazardous substances, water pollution, air pollution, or contamination of soil or groundwater.

When appropriate, these agencies will take action — perhaps through administrative actions, court proceedings, or other processes meant to bring property owners into compliance — in the interest of protecting human health and the environment.

Business owners with specific kinds of properties might find themselves more vulnerable to environmental enforcement actions: 

What Can Trigger an Environmental Enforcement Action?

Environmental agencies typically become aware of potential violations and initiate environmental enforcement actions through common activities like inspections, investigations, and complaints. 

Often, these agencies require regular reporting and monitoring to protect public health, as well as the overall health of local ecosystems. In simpler terms, they’re concerned about tracking pollutants like nitrogen dioxide and heavy metals to ensure that air and drinking water remain safe. They also want to detect habitat destruction, chemical runoff, or impacts to the climate as early as possible so clean-up efforts and other organizational changes can happen quickly. 

Two terms are especially relevant to these cases: Section 104(e) information requests and potentially responsible parties (PRPs).

Section 104(e) Information Requests

Under Section 104(e) of the federal Superfund law (CERCLA), the EPA can formally request information to investigate contamination and identify parties that may be responsible. These requests may ask about some of the following topics:

  • Property ownership and operations: Who owned, operated, or used the property during relevant periods.
  • Hazardous substances: What materials were handled, stored, released, or disposed of at the site.
  • Historical insurance coverage: Which insurers provided coverage during the relevant period, including information that may help identify policies no longer in the recipient’s records.

Receiving a 104(e) request does not automatically mean a business or property owner is liable for contamination. The EPA uses these requests to gather information as part of its investigation.

Potentially Responsible Parties (PRPs)

A potentially responsible party (PRP) is a person or organization that may be legally responsible for contamination at a Superfund site. Depending on the circumstances, this can include:

  • Current or former property owners and operators.
  • Businesses that generated hazardous waste.
  • Parties that arranged for hazardous substances to be transported or disposed of.
  • Parties involved in transporting hazardous substances to a disposal or treatment site.

The EPA may contact potentially responsible parties about investigating contamination and conducting or paying for cleanup. Identifying historical insurance coverage can be important when evaluating the potential costs of that responsibility. An EPA information request can help the agency investigate a site, but receiving one does not, by itself, designate the recipient as a PRP. 

Other Events That Can Trigger an Investigation

Environmental enforcement matters can also begin with routine compliance activities or new information about a property. Common triggers include:

  • Monitoring and reporting: Environmental testing or required reports reveal possible contamination, excessive emissions, or wastewater discharge violations.
  • Inspections: A facility inspection uncovers contaminated soil, improper hazardous-material handling, or other potential violations.
  • Spills or releases: An accidental release of chemicals or other hazardous substances prompts reporting or investigation.
  • Public complaints: Residents or other members of the public report suspected pollution or environmental harm.
  • Property transactions: Environmental due diligence identifies potential contamination before a sale or purchase. For brownfield properties or properties with a history of industrial or commercial use, an All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) investigation can help evaluate past uses and potential releases of hazardous substances.

For example, hazardous waste facilities may be subject to groundwater monitoring and other compliance requirements. Sampling results or facility records can help regulators determine whether the facility is meeting those requirements. Similarly, reviewing a property’s historical uses before a sale may uncover contamination that leads to further investigation.

What Happens During an Environmental Enforcement Action?

There’s no single process that applies to every environmental enforcement action. The steps depend on the type of violation, the agency involved, and the circumstances surrounding the environmental issue.

Generally, though, an agency will begin by investigating the potential violation. That could mean reviewing permits, records, and reports, talking with employees or facility representatives, inspecting the property, observing facility operations, taking photographs, or collecting and testing physical samples. Depending on the situation, investigators may also review environmental monitoring data or other information to determine whether the facility is complying with applicable requirements 

If the agency determines that there’s been a violation, it may take enforcement action. These actions could entail establishing cleanup or remediation requirements, seeking financial penalties, or even pursuing a case in court.

Environmental investigations and remediation can require specialized consultants, testing, engineering work, waste disposal, and other services. Some of these expenses may fall to the property owners, and, understandably, they may dread watching the costs quickly add up.

Can Insurance Cover Environmental Enforcement Actions?

Determining when or even how environmental contamination occurred can be tricky. Soil or groundwater pollution might not be discovered until years after the event that caused it. But depending on the specific insurance policy and facts of the claim, historical insurance coverage might help address certain costs associated with an environmental liability. That could include coverage for certain property damage or third-party liability, legal defense costs, or, in some circumstances, cleanup or remediation costs. 

Over the years, the businesses or organizations that existed within a particular property might have purchased commercial general liability (CGL) insurance policies. These policies generally provided coverage for certain third-party claims involving property damage. When it comes to environmental contamination, that coverage could potentially apply when a release or other environmental condition caused covered property damage or liability.

Whether a historical CGL policy can provide coverage for an environmental claim depends heavily on the policy language and the circumstances surrounding the contamination. The policy’s definition of an occurrence, the timing of the damage, pollution exclusions, and other provisions can all affect whether coverage applies. Some older CGL policies, for example, contained pollution exclusions that still allowed coverage for certain sudden and accidental releases.

This doesn’t necessarily mean that a CGL policy will pay the entire cost of cleaning up contaminated property. Coverage for cleanup costs can depend on the specific policy, the nature of the claim, applicable exclusions, and how courts have interpreted the policy. 

Why Are Historical Insurance Policies Important?

Environmental contamination doesn’t always happen all at once or become apparent right away. When the current property owner didn’t cause the contamination, and the insurance policy in place today isn’t applicable to the historical damage, older policies held by previous owners may be worth investigating.

Historical policies can also be important because their coverage terms and exclusions may differ from policies issued today. For example, pollution exclusions can affect whether a policy provides coverage for environmental contamination. Older CGL policies may have different pollution exclusion language, or they might have been issued before certain exclusions were added or changed. In other words, a historical policy that was in effect when the environmental damage occurred may be worth examining even if the property owner’s current policy wouldn’t provide coverage for the same issue. 

The insurance policy that may be germane to an environmental liability could have been issued decades before the contamination was discovered. This is especially important when the current property owner wasn’t operating at the property when the environmental damage occurred. The potentially relevant insurance coverage may belong to a previous owner, operator, or other business that was responsible for the property during the period when the contamination occurred.

A lot can change over several decades. A business may have changed ownership, moved locations, merged with another company, or changed its name. It may also have lost or discarded its older insurance records. The insurer that issued the policy could have changed names, merged with another insurer, or stopped operating entirely.

That’s why looking only at the insurance policies a property owner has today may not tell the whole story. Understanding the property’s ownership and business history, along with the insurance coverage that existed during those earlier periods, can help identify policies that may help the current owner manage costs associated with an environmental action. 

Unfortunately, those records aren’t always easy to find. But that doesn’t necessarily mean the coverage is gone. It does mean that the historical insurance record may need to be reconstructed.

How Can Insurance Archaeology Help With Environmental Enforcement Actions?

Insurance archaeology involves researching historical records to locate old insurance policies and reconstruct a company’s insurance history. When environmental contamination reaches back decades, an insurance archaeologist may need to piece together information from a variety of sources to identify the insurers and policies that could have provided coverage during the relevant period.

The archaeologist’s process can involve more than simply finding a policy number. The policy needs to be connected to the appropriate business, property, time period, and environmental issue. The terms of the policy also need to be evaluated in the context of the claim.

If historical insurance coverage does apply, those policies might mean that there’s a potential way for property owners to recover some of the costs related to the environmental liability. For business and property owners dealing with an environmental enforcement action, having an insurance archaeologist conduct this research can be a key piece of their financial puzzle.

Restorical Helps Uncover Historical Insurance Coverage

Restorical Research specializes in insurance archaeology and historical insurance research. If a property owner is dealing with environmental liabilities, our team can research the history of a property or business, identify historical insurers, locate old policies, and piece together insurance records when current documentation doesn’t paint the whole picture. Even if an insurer isn’t operating, we can still help identify historical coverage and organize the documentation property owners need to support the applicable claims process.

Environmental enforcement actions can create significant challenges for property owners and their representatives. If the environmental liability may involve historical insurance coverage, Restorical Research can help determine what coverage existed and whether it’s relevant to the current situation. 

Finding historical insurance coverage, including coverage that seems to be lost, can be crucial to reducing these cost burdens, which, if they’re significant enough, could threaten to damage or even derail a business entirely.

Contact us for a free case review.

This blog is not meant to represent a legal opinion. Restorical Research is not a law firm and is unable to provide legal advice.

We are not attorneys, this is not legal advice. 
Author

Ben Pariser

One of Ben’s favorite parts of insurance archeology is knowing Restorical is making a difference, helping to clean up the environment one polluted property at a time while also changing people’s lives.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

On This Page