Insurance Archaeology

Is There Any Reason to Keep Old Insurance Policies?

Ben Pariser


On This Page

Insurance liabilities can arise in many forms, often appearing unexpectedly and long after the events that triggered them. These liabilities can create substantial financial problems related to various issues, including product liability claims, workers’ compensation cases, environmental remediation, and other forms of legal and regulatory compliance. The cost of these liabilities can easily threaten a business’s financial stability and operational potential. Most business owners must realize that a solution for reducing these challenges may already exist within their old insurance policies.

This article highlights the many reasons why it is important to keep old insurance policies. By offering practical advice and insights into the strategic management of these documents, our goal is to give business owners the knowledge and tools necessary to protect their companies’ financial health and operational stability. Let’s dive in. 

Reasons to Keep Old Insurance Policies

Over our twenty-plus years of experience working as insurance archeologists, we’ve seen how critical it is to keep old insurance policies with thousands of businesses we’ve served. These documents are much more than historical insurance records. They are significant financial assets that hold the potential to offer protection against a wide range of legal problems. Here are some ways old insurance policies can help your business avoid unexpected disasters:

1. Comprehensive Coverage for Past Liabilities

Old insurance policies often offer much broader coverage terms than modern policies, including many exclusions that have become standard over the years. This can include claims stemming from many years in the past, such as environmental liabilities, asbestos exposure, employment practices, and product liabilities. Access to these historical policies can provide a safety net against various unexpected claims that might otherwise jeopardize your business’s financial stability.

2. Legal Defense and Settlement Costs

Old insurance policies cover more than just the liability itself. They can also cover the associated legal defense and settlement costs. This is particularly significant given the rising costs of litigation. In many cases, legal fees can be more overwhelming than settlement costs. Whether you’re facing a lawsuit from third-party claims or regulatory actions, the coverage provided by historical policies can save you substantial amounts.

3. Asset Recovery and Financial Strengthening

Finding and using old insurance policies can bring a lot of money that was previously hidden into your business. This money can help handle immediate legal problems and boost your company’s financial health, improving your balance sheet by turning hidden insurance benefits into recognizable financial resources. This boost is essential for businesses looking to attract investors, undergo valuation processes, or improve their financial standing.

4. Risk Transfer and Business Continuity

By covering past issues, historical insurance policies move the risk away from your business’s current financial resources. This is known as risk transfer. By taking the pressure off your current money, old insurance policies can help your business to continue running smoothly, even when big claims come up. It also allows you to use your current insurance coverage and money better, focusing on future challenges and growth opportunities.

5. Peace of Mind and Strategic Confidence

Knowing that past liabilities are covered gives business owners and stakeholders the peace of mind to focus on current operations and future strategies. There is also a level of confidence that can be appreciated due to the doctrine of utmost good faith, but we’ll make sure that all interactions meet those foundational insurance expectations. This confidence is essential for you to make wise strategic decisions, invest in new opportunities, and choose the overall direction of your business.

6. Enhancing Negotiation Leverage with Insurers

When business owners have a comprehensive understanding and documentation of historical insurance coverage, they are in a stronger position to negotiate claims and coverage with their insurers. This leverage can lead to much better settlements and coverage terms that benefit your business’s finances and operational strategy.

Examples of the Value of Keeping Old Insurance Policies

The following three situations exemplify the benefits of keeping old insurance policies, demonstrating their potential to mitigate financial burdens and contribute significantly to environmental and public health.

Product Liability Claims

A manufacturing company was confronted with legal claims alleging harm caused by products sold over twenty years ago. Without historical insurance documentation, the company faced the prospect of shouldering the entire financial burden of legal defense and potential settlements, threatening its ability to continue operating and earning money.

Without Old Insurance Policies

Without access to these documents, the company would likely experience significant financial stress that could lead to bankruptcy or drastically downsizing its operations to cover legal costs and settlements.

The Outcome with Old Insurance Policies

By leveraging old insurance policies that provided product liability coverage during the policy period in question, the company could significantly avoid the financial impact of the lawsuit. These policies covered legal defense costs and settlements, allowing the company to survive and continue operations without using its current financial resources.

Retroactive Workers’ Compensation Claims

A construction company was blindsided by workers’ compensation claims from former employees who developed health issues attributed to their work decades earlier. Because the company’s current insurance did not cover these retroactive claims, it faced a severe financial threat that could ruin the business altogether.

Without Old Insurance Policies

If the construction company only had its current applicable insurance policy as protection, it would have needed to compensate all the former employees using all the money left in its bank accounts, and that still wouldn’t have been enough. The business almost certainly would have failed or would have taken years to recover if it managed to survive.

The Outcome with Old Insurance Policies

By locating old insurance policies that covered the relevant employment periods, the company could address the outstanding claims without direct financial losses, remaining protected from financial ruin while supporting the well-being of the former employees.

Environmental Remediation of Contaminated Property

A real estate investment firm discovered environmental contamination on a property it purchased from a previous owner. The cleanup costs and potential regulatory fines presented a significant financial challenge that threatened to ruin the investment and unravel the firm’s financial planning.

Without Old Insurance Policies

Without access to old insurance policies, the firm would have to absorb all the remediation costs, leading to severe financial losses, including the loss of the property’s value and the expense of regulatory penalties.

The Outcome with Old Insurance Policies

Since the firm had transferred the previous owner’s old insurance policy that covered environmental liabilities when it purchased the property, the historical policy covered most of the cleanup costs. This preserved the firm’s financial resources and maintained the property’s value.

Practical Tips for Managing and Retaining Old Insurance Documents

To take full advantage of the benefits that historical insurance policies can provide your business, business owners must create a system to manage and store old insurance documents effectively. Here are some practical tips to ensure your insurance documents are well-organized, accessible, and preserved over time.

  1. Create a formal document retention policy that specifies how long your company should keep insurance documents. While your instinct might be to discard old policies, the benefits we’ve just explained are why you should keep these documents indefinitely.
  2. Maintain a well-organized filing system for insurance documents categorized by policy type, coverage period, and insurance company, along with any relevant billing statements or bank statements, so that it’s easy to retrieve documents if needed. Also, we recommend creating a physical and a digital archive to ensure redundancy.
  3. Digitize paper policy documents to preserve them and facilitate easy access. Use secure, cloud-based storage solutions to back up digital documents to protect against hardware failure, natural disasters, or cyber threats.
  4. Conduct regular reviews and updates of your insurance document archive to ensure it remains current and comprehensive. Update the archive with new policies, amendments, or relevant communication with insurance companies.
  5. Train key personnel within your organization in the document management system so they understand the importance of insurance documents even after a policy expires. Training should cover how to file new documents, retrieve existing ones, and recognize when to consult with experts.
  6. Consider partnering with insurance archaeology experts. These experts can provide valuable insights into the potential benefits of your existing insurance portfolio and help you create document management strategies based on your business’s needs.
  7. Implement security measures to protect the confidentiality of your insurance documents and ensure that your document management practices comply with relevant regulations, such as data protection laws.
  8. Plan for business transitions by incorporating insurance document management into your business continuity and transition plans to ensure that successors or new management teams know and understand the importance of these documents.

Understanding Environmental Remediation and Insurance Coverage

Environmental remediation involves the removal of pollution or contaminants from environmental media such as soil, groundwater, sediment, or surface water. This action is crucial for protecting human health and restoring the environment to a safe and usable condition. The process can be complex, costly, and time-consuming, requiring significant financial resources. Historical insurance policies may cover a wide range of environmental issues, including but not limited to

  • Cleanup of hazardous waste or pollutants from a site.
  • Legal liabilities for accidental contamination or pollution.
  • Costs associated with the restoration of natural resources.
  • Expenses related to investigating and assessing environmental damage.

Identifying and leveraging old insurance policies for environmental remediation presents challenges and opportunities. The primary challenge lies in locating, interpreting, and proving the applicability of these policies to current environmental issues. The opportunity, however, is substantial: the potential to fund remediation efforts without depleting current financial resources, thereby preserving the business’s fiscal health and operational continuity.

Restorical Research’s expertise in insurance archaeology enables businesses to navigate these complexities, uncovering and utilizing historical insurance assets to fund environmental remediation. Our work facilitates compliance and cleanup and contributes to the broader goal of sustainable business practices and environmental stewardship.

You Never Know When You Will Need Old Insurance Policies

By adhering to these practical tips, businesses can maximize the potential benefits of their historical insurance policies, safeguard against future liabilities, and enhance their overall risk management strategy. Managing and retaining insurance documents is an ongoing process integral to the business’s financial health and operational stability. At Restorical Research, we are committed to assisting companies in navigating the complexities of insurance archaeology as it relates to environmental remediation, unlocking the hidden value within their old insurance policies, and establishing robust document management practices. By recognizing the significance of these historical documents, businesses can secure a more resilient and prosperous future.

We are not attorneys, this is not legal advice. 

Ben Pariser

One of Ben’s favorite parts of insurance archeology is knowing Restorical is making a difference, helping to clean up the environment one polluted property at a time while also changing people’s lives.


On This Page

Get Started

Find Your Lost
Insurance Policies

For over the past 20+ years, Restorical has meticulously audited the insurance industry, including each individual insurance carrier, leveraging this real-world experience and our proprietary database to the advantage of our policyholder clients.